Recent News and Opinion
2015/7/28 - Letters: Resident Concerned about HAARP Weapon
2015/7/27 - Lewisville Police Offer Exchange Zone
2015/7/26 - Coach Joe's Hat Tricks Presents: Rob Hunts 60th Birthday Guit...
2015/7/26 - Men's Volleyball Getting Started Within LISD
2015/7/26 - I-35 Accident Kills One, Injures Two
2015/7/24 - Upcoming Events Around Lewisville and the Surrounding Area
2015/7/23 - Lewisville Police Investigate Homicide; One Dead
2015/7/21 - Water Rates to Rise
2015/7/19 - Food Reviews: Old House BBQ
2015/7/19 - Citizen Takes Action on Unwanted Newspaper Litter
2015/7/18 - Upcoming Events Around Lewisville and the Surrounding Area
2015/7/14 - City Schedules Mosquito Spraying
2015/7/11 - Saturday Briefs
2015/7/11 - Upcoming Closures on the 35Express Project
2015/7/11 - 35Express Project to Create 100 New Jobs
2015/7/11 - Free Garden Secrets Class: Wicked Plants
2015/7/11 - Transportation Funding Opportunities and Projects to be Explored J...
2015/7/10 - Fire Damages Building at Bassword Manor Apartments - Six Families ...
2015/7/6 - Updated: Flower Mound HS Student Photographer Forced to Take Down ...
2015/7/6 - City Council to Hear Presentation on LED Light Strips
2015/7/4 - Food Reviews: Joe Avezzano's Hat Tricks
2015/6/30 - Updated: Councilman Arrested for DWI
2015/6/30 - Updated: First Same Sex Marriage License Issued in Lewisville
2015/6/28 - Lewisville Welcomes Pomegranate Underground
2015/6/28 - Movie Review: Me, Earl and the Dying Girl
Recent Reader Comments
2015/7/28 12:56 - Re: Letters: Resident Concerned about HAARP Weapon (Anonymous)
2015/7/28 11:36 - Re: Letters: Resident Concerned about HAARP Weapon (Anonymous)
2015/7/27 10:13 - Re: I-35 Accident Kills One, Injures Two (Anonymous)
2015/7/27 10:12 - Re: Lewisville Police Investigate Homicide; One Dead (Anonymous)
2015/7/26 13:33 - Re: Lewisville Police Investigate Homicide; One Dead (Anonymous)
2015/7/24 11:47 - Re: Lewisville Police Investigate Homicide; One Dead (Anonymous)
2015/7/24 9:37 - Re: Lewisville Police Investigate Homicide; One Dead (Anonymous)
2015/7/23 23:46 - Re: Lewisville Police Investigate Homicide; One Dead (WhosPlayin)
2015/7/23 18:45 - Re: Lewisville Police Investigate Homicide; One Dead (Anonymous)
2015/7/23 17:27 - Re: Lewisville Police Investigate Homicide; One Dead (Anonymous)
2015/7/23 15:14 - Re: Lewisville Police Investigate Homicide; One Dead (WhosPlayin)
2015/7/23 14:45 - Re: Lewisville Police Investigate Homicide; One Dead (Anonymous)
2015/7/23 13:36 - Re: Lewisville Police Investigate Homicide; One Dead (Anonymous)
2015/7/23 12:31 - Re: Water Rates to Rise (WhosPlayin)
2015/7/22 10:36 - Re: Water Rates to Rise (Anonymous)
2015/7/21 20:35 - Re: Food Reviews: Old House BBQ (Anonymous)
2015/7/12 5:03 - Re: 35Express Project to Create 100 New Jobs (Anonymous)
2015/7/11 21:53 - Re: Saturday Briefs (Anonymous)
2015/7/11 21:47 - Re: Saturday Briefs (Anonymous)
2015/7/10 0:27 - Re: City Council to Hear Presentation on LED Light Strips (Anonymous)
2015/7/6 1:20 - Re: Updated: Councilman Arrested for DWI (Anonymous)
2015/7/2 17:17 - Re: Councilman Arrested for DWI (fvaughan)

Qualifications for Lewisville City Council (Updated)

The Editor's Column
Posted by WhosPlayin on 2015/1/27 19:00:00 (3877 reads)

Open in new windowHaving followed the Lewisville City Council and city elections for years, it has become clear to me that it helps the discussion to lay out some framework on what types of qualifications make a good council member. As candidates announce their campaigns, we can examine them in light of these qualifications rather than the more squishy criteria of who we like, and who is most popular.

So here's my current list of what I consider to be qualifications:

• Has high intellectual capacity, and able to look beyond the superficial and quickly understand the nuance and complexity of the issues that face government.

• Has lived in the City of Lewisville a sufficient length of time to understand the demographics, the trends, the history, and the shared values of our citizens. Definitely not less than 5 years, but preferably more than 10.

• Has an up-to-date voter registration and a good history of voting in all elections, especially local ones, which evidence a long-term concern for local issues.

• Has consistently followed City Council actions, attended meetings, workshops, budget hearings, and retreats. Given that all of the meetings are open to the public, a candidate should have actively attended meetings-- not only to stay up-to-date on the issues frequently discussed, but to show a dedication and availability that will be required once they get on Council.

• Has demonstrated leadership by serving on one or more of the City's boards or commissions.

• Has demonstrated commitment to the City by volunteering for, or supporting one or more of the City's non-profit or civic groups.

• Is more dedicated to the City of Lewisville than to a political party or ideology. Partisan politics have ruined Washington and Austin. They cloud judgement and make it hard to work together for pragmatic solutions.

• Is not using the office for personal achievement or gain, or as a stepping stone to higher office. Time and time again we see politicians who see municipal service as nothing more than a platform for grandstanding and demagoguery. These people waste city resources and create strife, then run for higher office, leaving others to deal with the consequences and cleanup.

• Understands the relationship between city services, property values and quality of life.

• Demonstrates compassion for mankind by charity.

• Lives to a high standard of ethics in all that they do.

• Pays their taxes. The biggest part of the City Council's role is to set the budget and corresponding tax rate each year. It is hypocrisy for a council member not to be current on their city taxes.

• Puts the health and safety of the citizens above all else.

• Capable of listening to multiple points of view, and ensuring that all concerns are heard and addressed.

• Dedicated to seeking truthful information-- not just the information that may support their particular view on something.

• Doesn't have character flaws or a severe or untreated mental illness that would interfere with or distract from accomplishing the City's business.

• The candidate should not have an axe to grind. In other words, he or she should not be running because of a strong feeling or passion about one issue, or because the council ticked you off about something. The person MUST be able to put single issues behind them and focus on all the other issues that will come before them without having their judgment clouded by holding grudges over votes on the issue they feel strongest about. (Borrowed from Ken, below)

• Has the ability to understand the differences between local, state, and federal government issues, and work within the scope and constraints imposed on local government from above. (Borrowed from BC - via Facebook)

• Must be honest and truthful, and hold truthfulness as a strong personal value. Liars have no business in a position of public trust. Honesty is paramount.



I fully understand that not every candidate is going to meet up to all of these. In fact, there's a good chance that no candidate will meet all of these. But I think we need to look at them all in that light and choose the best when the time comes.

For the office of Mayor, specifically, the following additional qualifications help quite a bit:
• Outgoing personality.

• Charisma

• Tact

• Leadership

• Ability to keep conversations on-topic and run a meeting efficiently

• Prior experience on City Council

• Negotiating experience, especially with large or complex deals


What I absolutely and unequivocally reject as criteria for electing a Council Member or Mayor:
• Race, ethnicity, gender or sexual preference

• Religious affiliation, church attendance, or lack of affiliation. Anyone can profess a belief, but actions speak louder than words. It is at worst bigoted, and at best mentally lazy to vote for someone because they follow the same theology as you do, or vote against them because they believe or worship differently than you.

• Political party affiliation or activism. Local government is non-partisan for a reason. Partisan issues typically have no outlet at the local level because local government is constrained by higher government. Further, hyper-partisanship is detrimental because it polarizes and divides people who need to be working together on solutions that satisfy a broad consensus.


What I think are disqualifiers:
• Being a liar. Someone who will lie for you will lie to you. There is no value to lying even when one thinks the end justifies the means, since a liar usually lies to himself about the end and the means.

• Having a recent or serious criminal record or pending criminal case. A lot of people make dumb decisions when they're young, or do something minor like get a traffic ticket, and that's not what I'm talking about.

• Running for personal or business gain. If you're in it to pad your resume, or get publicity for yourself or your business, then save everyone's time and find something else to do. You need to care about the City.

• Being a racist or a bigot. There is no place in government at all for anyone who looks down on people for their race, ethnicity, color, gender, or sexual orientation.


What are your thoughts? I want to hear them. Leave a comment.

First published 1/27/2011, updated and re-published 1/28/2015.


Related Links:
- The Public School Trustee's Pledge

Keywords:
- MunicipalElection2015
- MunicipalElection2014
- MunicipalElection2013
- MunicipalElection2012
- Municipals2011

- Rating: 10.00 (2 votes) - {$lang_ratethisnews}
 
The comments are owned by the poster. We aren't responsible for their content.

Poster Thread
kjudk1955
Posted: 2011/1/27 11:10  Updated: 2011/2/24 16:26
Guest Columnist (Verified User)
Joined: 2007/4/26
From: Lewisville, TX
Posts: 88
 Re: Qualifications for Lewisville City Council
Great list! I especially like your last rejected criteria about partisanship. I have found over the years that party lines blur when it comes to local issues. As one who is generally considered liberal, I have found myself working side by side with some of the most conservative people I know. Conversely, I have been at odds on some issues with those I usually agree with on state and federal issues.

I would add only one more item to your qualifications list:

- The candidate should not have an axe to grind. In other words, he or she should not be running because of a strong feeling or passion about one issue, or because the council ticked you off about something. The person MUST be able to put single issues behind them and focus on all the other issues that will come before them without having their judgment clouded by holding grudges over votes on the issue they feel strongest about.
Reply

Poster Thread
bullbuster
Posted: 2011/1/28 11:12  Updated: 2011/1/28 11:12
Registered User (Unverified)
Joined: 2010/3/4
From:
Posts: 20
 Re: Qualifications for Lewisville City Council
Excellent!!! Bless you my sons!!!
Bet Ken recalls one mayor whose first actions upon assuming office were an attempt to begin repaying favors to supportive members of her chosen party. Her partisan actions were challenged by a citizen and the mayor later agreed that her attempted actions were inappropriate. Ah! The good ole days.
Reply

Poster Thread
Anonymous
Posted: 2011/1/28 22:33  Updated: 2011/1/29 12:54
 Re: Qualifications for Lewisville City Council
My Comments?...hhmm...let me think...

TJ GILMORE! VOTE YES!~ I'll put a hundred signs in my yard my friend!
Reply

Poster Thread
WhosPlayin
Posted: 2011/2/24 14:41  Updated: 2011/2/24 14:41
Editor
Joined: 2008/12/12
From:
Posts: 4085
 Racism is a disqualifier
Most human beings end up with at least some subconscious prejudice. It's just the way the human brain works, because we're pattern recognizers. When people see patterns, such as stereotypes playing out, our brains subconsciously try to complete the pattern, whether or not it's empirically true, and without regard to any sort of morality.

Normal decent human beings with a basic level of maturity are able to suppress the lazy reliance on these patterns and use logic, empathy, and morality to guide their interactions with their fellow man. Most good people recoil at the thought of discrimination against others based on aspects of their person that they can't control. As Dr. King said, "I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character."

Racists and bigots consciously embrace the patterns of stereotypes and use them as a crutch. My theory is that many of these people have an inferiority complex so severe that it makes them feel better about themselves if they can have someone or some group to hate. It allows them to focus on the perceived shortcomings or inferiority of others rather than to deal with their own faults. Then again, a sociopath is incapable of empathy, and some racists may fall into that category.

Many otherwise good people will at some point in their life allow some overt prejudice to take hold, but many times maturity and life experience or a spiritual awakening will turn them around. The late Robert Byrd was one example of a turnaround.

So, even though it seems like this could go without saying, I'm adding this as a disqualifier to serve on City Council. Having a racist incident or thought pattern in one's distant past is one thing, but to be actively and overtly racist, using racial slurs or talking in derogatory terms about minorities is intolerable in a position of leadership. Voters ought to pay special attention to this one.
Reply

Poster Thread
rbiceo
Posted: 2011/2/24 23:03  Updated: 2011/2/24 23:03
Joined: 2011/2/22
From: Mckinney, TX
Posts: 3
 Re: Racism is a disqualifier
Sad to even have to mention it. You are absolutely right Steve.
Reply


Other articles
2015/7/28 8:11:46 - Letters: Resident Concerned about HAARP Weapon
2015/7/27 13:04:19 - Lewisville Police Offer Exchange Zone
2015/7/26 13:10:00 - Coach Joe's Hat Tricks Presents: Rob Hunts 60th Birthday Guitar Jam
2015/7/26 9:10:00 - Men's Volleyball Getting Started Within LISD
2015/7/26 8:30:00 - I-35 Accident Kills One, Injures Two
2015/7/24 11:51:22 - Upcoming Events Around Lewisville and the Surrounding Area
2015/7/23 13:10:00 - Lewisville Police Investigate Homicide; One Dead
2015/7/21 8:04:18 - Water Rates to Rise
2015/7/19 18:50:00 - Food Reviews: Old House BBQ
2015/7/19 13:42:26 - Citizen Takes Action on Unwanted Newspaper Litter


The Lewisville Texan Journal is a service of SagePost, Inc.
Login to Comment
User:
Pass:
Remember me
Lost your password?
Create New Account